The 2005 Volkswagen Golf represents the fifth-generation version of the German firm’s all-conquering family hatchback. The Mk5 went on sale in the UK in 2004 and was available in both three-door and five-door hatchback body styles, but the 2005 version came before the five-door estate variant became available in 2007. The Mk5 was a huge improvement on the Mk4 it replaced, with a much more sophisticated rear suspension giving it the deft ride-and-handling balance to trouble even the Ford Focus of the time. It felt posh inside, it had a practical cabin, and it looked super-smart and had a posh image. Everything a Golf should be, then.

Strengths:

Looks good inside and out
Great to drive
Wide choice of engines and trims

Weaknesses:

Some reliability issues with the Mk5
Lower-spec models are rather basic
Some of the diesels are noisy

Is the 2005 Volkswagen Golf better than the 2005 Honda Civic?

That depends on what you’re after. If you’re after a sophisticated-feeling driving experience, with a smooth ride, deft handling and slick controls, then the VW will suit you better. It also has a more ergonomically sound dashboard and better rear visibility. However, if you want your car to be reliable - and we can’t see why you wouldn’t - then choose the Honda. It had a great record in this regard, where the Mk5 Golf was fraught with issues.