The BMW X5 and Audi Q7 are two of the most prominent luxury SUVs on the market, offering a compelling blend of premium amenities, spacious interiors, and powerful performance. While they share some similarities, each model has its own unique strengths and characteristics that cater to different preferences and needs.
In this comparison, we'll delve into the nuances of these two SUVs, exploring their practicality, driving dynamics, technology and equipment offerings, and running costs. Whether you're a family seeking a versatile and upscale hauler or an enthusiast craving a dynamic driving experience, this analysis will help you make an informed decision.
BMW X5 vs Audi Q7
Practicality
Both the BMW X5 and Audi Q7 excel in terms of practicality, offering ample interior space and versatile cargo capabilities. The X5 comes standard with a split tailgate, a 40:20:40 split-folding rear seat, and an impressive 650 litres of boot space, which can expand to a cavernous 1,870 litres with the rear seats folded down. Additionally, it's available with an optional third-row seating package, making it a viable option for larger families.
The Q7, on the other hand, boasts an even larger boot capacity of 780 litres with five seats in place and a massive 1,908 litres with all the rear seats folded. Its middle-row seats can slide backwards and forwards individually, and their backrests can be reclined or set upright to maximise luggage space. While the third-row seats in the Q7 offer slightly less head and legroom than those in the BMW, they remain suitable for shorter trips with adults.
In terms of outright practicality, the Audi Q7 just about has the edge over the BMW X5, thanks to its slightly larger boot capacity and more flexible seating configurations. However, these are both massively practical (and well, just massive) family SUVs.
Driving Impressions
While both the BMW X5 and Audi Q7 offer a range of powerful engine options, the driving experiences they deliver are somewhat different. The X5 is available with a choice of straight-six petrol and diesel engines, as well as potent V8 variants in the M Sport and X5 M Competition models. Even the entry-level xDrive30d diesel packs an impressive 282bhp and can accelerate from 0-62mph in just 6.1 seconds, defying its size and weight.
The Q7, on the other hand, primarily relies on a robust 3.0-litre six-cylinder diesel engine, available in either 272bhp or 218bhp variants. The higher-powered diesel option delivers hot hatch-like acceleration, despite the Q7's substantial curb weight. The V8 SQ7 is the performance flagship with 663lb ft of torque!
Where the X5 truly shines is in its handling dynamics. Thanks to its precise steering, responsive chassis, and well-controlled body roll, it delivers a remarkably engaging and agile driving experience - especially for an SUV of its size. The Q7, while competent, doesn't quite match the BMW's level of driver engagement, although it remains composed and capable, especially when equipped with the optional air suspension.
Both SUVs feature all-wheel-drive systems and offer various driving modes that allow you to tailor the driving experience to your preferences, whether you prioritise comfort, efficiency, or performance.
In terms of outright driving pleasure, the BMW X5 has a slight edge over the Audi Q7, offering a more engaging and dynamic driving experience without compromising on performance or practicality. However, the Q7's potent diesel engines and composed ride quality make it a compelling choice for those who prioritise effortless cruising and straight-line performance.
Technology and Equipment
Both the BMW X5 and Audi Q7 are well-equipped luxury SUVs, offering a wealth of advanced technologies and premium features. The X5's base xLine trim comes generously appointed with heated front sports seats, LED headlights, air suspension, DAB connectivity, and wireless charging. Upgrading to the M Sport trim adds M-specific interior and exterior enhancements, as well as an improved braking system.
The Q7, on the other hand, impresses with its fully digital cockpit, featuring a configurable Virtual Cockpit display and two stacked touchscreens for the infotainment system. This setup gives the Q7's interior a distinctly high-tech and modern feel.
While the X5 offers a range of upgrades and equipment packages, including the high-performance X5 M Competition model with 617bhp, the Q7 counters with the potent SQ7 variant, which delivers blistering acceleration for an SUV of its size.
Both vehicles offer a comprehensive suite of advanced driver assistance features and cutting-edge infotainment systems, ensuring a safe and connected driving experience.
In terms of technology and equipment, it's a close call between the two SUVs. The BMW X5 offers a more traditional approach to luxury, with a focus on premium materials and customisation options, while the Audi Q7 embraces a more modern and tech-forward design aesthetic. Ultimately, the choice may come down to personal preferences and priorities.
Running Costs
Running costs are an important consideration when evaluating luxury SUVs, and both the BMW X5 and Audi Q7 offer a range of options to suit different budgets and needs.
The most efficient model in the X5 range is the plug-in hybrid xDrive45e, which emits as little as 27g/km of CO2 and can average a claimed fuel economy of 235.4mpg on the WLTP cycle. This makes it an attractive option for business users seeking to minimise Benefit-in-Kind (BIK) company car tax liabilities.
The diesel xDrive40d and xDrive30d variants of the X5 offer more modest fuel economy, averaging around 35mpg, while the petrol xDrive40i is the least efficient of the standard range, averaging just 25.7mpg.
On the Audi side, the Q7 3.0 TDI diesel models offer respectable fuel economy, with the 215bhp version achieving 52.3mpg on the combined cycle and the 268bhp variant returning 47.9mpg. The mild-hybrid diesel models introduced in the 2019 facelift promise improved real-world efficiency.
The Q7 e-tron plug-in hybrid's fuel economy will vary significantly based on how often it is recharged, but owners with shorter commutes and access to home charging could potentially go weeks without using any fuel.
At the higher end of the performance spectrum, the BMW X5 M Competition and Audi SQ7 models are predictably less efficient, with the former averaging around 22.1mpg and the latter expected to deliver high-20s mpg in real-world driving conditions.
Insurance premiums and maintenance costs will also be higher for these high-performance variants, reflecting their elevated values and capabilities.
While neither the BMW X5 nor the Audi Q7 will be particularly cheap to run, especially in their higher-performance guises, both manufacturers offer fixed-price servicing packages to help minimise unexpected costs. Additionally, both vehicles are expected to hold their value well on the used market, mitigating some of the long-term ownership expenses.
In terms of running costs, the Audi Q7 has a slight edge over the BMW X5, particularly when considering the impressive fuel economy of its diesel models and the potential savings offered by the e-tron plug-in hybrid variant. However, the X5's plug-in hybrid option and competitive residual values help narrow the gap.
Verdict
Both the BMW X5 and Audi Q7 are exceptional luxury SUVs, offering a compelling blend of practicality, performance, and premium amenities. The choice between these two models ultimately comes down to personal tastes, brand affinity and a few key areas of difference.
The BMW X5 stands out for its engaging driving dynamics, precise handling, and a wide range of potent engine options, including the high-performance X5 M Competition. Its optional third-row seating and impressive safety ratings make it an attractive choice for families seeking a practical and secure luxury SUV with a dynamic edge.
On the other hand, the Audi Q7 excels in terms of outright practicality, boasting a slightly larger boot capacity and more flexible seating configurations. Its fully digital cockpit and tech-forward interior design give it a modern and high-tech feel, while its diesel and plug-in hybrid models offer impressive fuel efficiency and potential cost savings.
If driving pleasure and an engaging on-road experience are your top priorities, the BMW X5 has a slight edge over the Audi Q7. However, if practicality, interior versatility, and potential cost savings are more important factors, the Q7 may be the better choice.
Ultimately, both SUVs are exceptional in their own right, and both scored maximum five star ratings in our reviews. So whichever you choose, you can expect a luxurious, capable, and technologically advanced SUV that delivers a rewarding ownership experience.