The Hyundai Ioniq 5 and BMW i4 might not seem like obvious rivals: after all, the Hyundai is a crossover, whereas the BMW is a sleek four-door coupe. However, so successful has Hyundai's match upmarket been that there is every chance you might be cross-shopping these two cars. In this comparison, we'll see how they stack up.
The Ioniq 5 impresses with its remarkably spacious interior and cavernous boot space, making it an excellent choice for families. In contrast, the i4 prioritises a sportier driving experience while still providing a decent amount of room. Both cars boast an impressive range and cutting-edge technology, but their pricing and equipment levels differ. By the end of this comparison, we will give you a clear understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of each model.
Hyundai Ioniq 5 vs BMW i4
Practicality
The Hyundai Ioniq 5 is a remarkably practical family car, defying its hatchback-like proportions (really it's more of an SUV/crossover) with a spacious and airy cabin. The minimalist dashboard design creates a sense of openness, while the upright twin 12-inch screens provide a modern and user-friendly interface. The front seats offer ample room, and the rear seats boast limo-like legroom, with the ability to slide forwards and backwards and recline for added comfort.
With a generous 527-litre boot capacity, the Ioniq 5 can swallow a substantial amount of luggage, making it well-suited for family adventures. The flat floor in the rear further enhances passenger comfort. While the BMW i4 is a more conventional choice, it still offers decent practicality for a saloon. The 470-litre boot has a large opening, and the rear seats fold flat in a 40/20/40 split, extending the luggage bay to carry larger loads.
However, the i4's sloping roofline can make accessing the rear seats slightly more challenging, and rear legroom may feel a bit tight for taller passengers, especially compared to the Ioniq 5's generous proportions. If outright practicality is your top priority, the Hyundai Ioniq 5 has a clear edge over the BMW i4.
Driving Impressions
While the Hyundai Ioniq 5 offers a serene and relaxed driving experience, the BMW i4 is designed to deliver a more engaging and sporty performance. The i4's precise and responsive steering, combined with its keen handling, makes it a joy to drive, even at relatively low speeds. The peculiar electric soundtrack orchestrated by Hans Zimmer adds to the excitement, although it can be turned off for those who prefer a quieter cabin.
The i4 eDrive40 model's 5.7-second 0-62mph time delivers exhilarating acceleration, while the i4 M50 takes it a step further with a blistering 3.9-second sprint. However, some drivers may find the throttle response, especially in Sport mode, a bit too aggressive. The Ioniq 5, on the other hand, prioritises a more comfortable and composed ride, although it can feel a bit floaty over undulations. That said, the range-topping Ioniq 5 N is a true performance car with 641bhp and handling to match. Whisper it, but we'd even take one over the i4 M50.
N model aside, when it comes to pure driving enjoyment, the BMW i4 is the winner, offering a level of engagement and performance that sets it apart from the more sedate Ioniq 5. However, the Hyundai's smooth and relaxed demeanour may be preferable for those seeking a serene family hauler.
Technology and Equipment
Both the Hyundai Ioniq 5 and BMW i4 come well-equipped with the latest technology and infotainment systems. The Ioniq 5 offers a comprehensive suite of standard features, including adaptive cruise control, semi-autonomous driving modes, a large touchscreen infotainment system with over-the-air updates, wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, and even wireless phone charging across the range.
The BMW i4, while offering a more conventional cabin layout, doesn't skimp on technology either. The large touchscreen system, housed alongside the driver's display, features the latest BMW Operating System 8 with voice control, navigation with charger search, and online streaming services. However, some features like keyless entry, a heated steering wheel, and BMW's semi-autonomous driving assistant require additional costs.
While the Ioniq 5's infotainment system may not be as graphically polished as BMW's offerings, it remains user-friendly and packed with features. What is doesn't have is BMW's renowned iDrive system, which some may find more intuitive and logical to navigate thanks to its physical rotary controller.
In terms of standard equipment, the Ioniq 5 generally offers a more comprehensive suite of features across its trim levels, while the i4 requires opting for higher and costlier trims or adding packages to match the Hyundai's level of equipment. Ultimately, both cars provide a wealth of technology and convenience features, but the Ioniq 5 offers better value for money in this regard.
Running Costs
When it comes to running costs, both the Hyundai Ioniq 5 and BMW i4 offer significant savings compared to their petrol or diesel counterparts, provided you can charge at home. However, the i4 carries a higher initial purchase price, starting at more than £50,000 topping out at over £70,000 for the M50 variant. In contrast, the Ioniq 5 is more affordable, with prices ranging from around £40,000 to £48,000.
While the i4 may be more expensive upfront, its running costs are still lower than comparable petrol or diesel models. Electricity is generally cheaper than traditional fuels, and the i4 is estimated to cost around 5p per mile to run (the actual cost will depend on your electricity tariff), compared to roughly 15p per mile for a petrol car achieving 40mpg.
The Ioniq 5's running costs are similarly impressive - and as with the BMW, by utilising off-peak tariffs, costs can be reduced even further.
While the BMW i4 may be more expensive upfront, its running costs are competitive with the Ioniq 5, and both cars offer substantial savings over their petrol or diesel counterparts. Ultimately, the decision may come down just how much you're prepared to pay for that premium BMW badge.
Verdict
In the battle between the Hyundai Ioniq 5 and BMW i4, there is no clear-cut winner. Both cars excel in their respective areas, catering to slightly different priorities and preferences.
The Hyundai Ioniq 5 is an exceptional choice for families seeking a practical, spacious, and well-equipped electric vehicle. Its cavernous interior, generous boot space, and comprehensive suite of features make it an ideal family hauler. While it may not offer the same level of driving excitement as the BMW i4, the Ioniq 5 delivers a serene and comfortable driving experience, making it a compelling option for those prioritising practicality and value.
On the other hand, the BMW i4 shines as a driver's car, offering a level of engagement and performance across the board that sets it apart from its rivals. With its precise handling, exhilarating acceleration, and premium interior, the i4 caters to those seeking a more dynamic and sporty driving experience. However, it comes at a higher price point and may not be as practical as the Ioniq 5 for larger families or those with substantial cargo needs.
Ultimately, the choice between these two vehicles will depend on your specific priorities and lifestyle. If practicality, value, and a comfortable family hauler are your top concerns, the Hyundai Ioniq 5 is an excellent choice. However, if you prioritise driving dynamics, performance, and a more premium experience, the BMW i4 will be the better fit, albeit at a higher cost.